Statement of Appeal in a Compensation Claim in Kuwait: Requirements, Deadlines and Sample Template

A statement of appeal in a compensation claim in Kuwait sets out the appellant’s objections to a compensation judgment, the grounds of appeal and the relief sought. Preparing it begins with reviewing the judgment and case file, checking whether an appeal is available and identifying the applicable deadline, then linking each objection to supporting evidence.

An appeal may challenge the dismissal of a compensation claim, an award considered too low or an amount considered excessive. In every case, the statement should clearly identify the alleged error in the judgment and explain how correcting it supports the outcome requested.

What Does Appealing a Compensation Judgment Mean?

An appeal brings the dispute before the court competent to hear the challenge, within the scope of the part of the judgment appealed against. A claimant seeking a higher award therefore needs a different statement from a defendant seeking to set aside liability or reduce the amount awarded.

Not every compensation judgment can be appealed in the same way. The issuing court, the value of the claim, the nature of the judgment and any applicable special rules must be examined.

Scope of this article: Civil and commercial judgments in compensation claims. Separate appeal rules should be checked before using this template for a civil claim attached to criminal proceedings.

Deadline for Appealing a Compensation Judgment in Kuwait

The general appeal period is 30 days, reduced to 15 days in urgent matters, unless a special statutory rule applies.

The appeal period usually runs from the date the judgment is issued. In certain circumstances, it runs from service of the judgment, including where the party against whom judgment was entered attended none of the hearings and submitted no defence memorandum. The deadline should therefore not automatically be calculated from the date a copy of the judgment is received.

The period is calculated from the day following the event that starts it, taking into account public holidays, extensions and any special provisions. Failure to meet the deadline results in loss of the right to appeal.

Source: Judicial principles collections published by Kuwait’s Ministry of Justice, section on appeal deadlines.

Requirements for an Admissible Appeal

Before preparing a statement of appeal against a compensation judgment, check:

• Whether the judgment is appealable under the applicable jurisdictional rules, monetary thresholds and statutory exceptions.

• The appellant’s standing and legal interest in having the judgment changed.

• Whether the appellant has accepted the judgment in a manner that prevents an appeal.

• Compliance with the correct appeal deadline.

• Compliance with the required contents, procedures and signature requirements.

• Payment of the applicable fees and security deposit, where required.

A successful appeal does not necessarily require a new document. It may challenge how the court interpreted a document already in the file or how it applied the law.

Grounds for Appealing a Compensation Judgment

Simply stating that “the compensation is inappropriate” is insufficient. It is better to identify the objection, its supporting material and its effect on the outcome.

These are examples for analysing the file, rather than standard grounds suitable for every case. Any ground unsupported by the case documents should be omitted.

Procedure for Appealing a Compensation Judgment

1. Review the judgment: Read its reasoning and operative part, and compare them with the final relief sought before the first-instance court.

2. Identify the deadline and competent court: Consider the judgment and the circumstances of attendance and service.

3. Prepare the file: Gather the judgment, power of attorney, original statement of claim, memoranda, documents and expert reports.

4. Draft the statement of appeal: Identify the judgment, grounds and requested relief precisely.

5. File the statement: Submit it to the registry of the competent court and complete the registration requirements.

6. Follow up on service and hearings: Ensure that memoranda and documents are submitted on time.

Under Article 137 of the Civil and Commercial Procedure Law, the security deposit differs according to the court that issued the judgment: KWD 20 for judgments of the Partial Court and KWD 50 for judgments of the Court of First Instance (Full Court), subject to statutory exemptions. This deposit is separate from court fees and lawyers’ fees.

Source: Civil and Commercial Procedure Law, Article 137.

Sample Statement of Appeal in a Compensation Claim in Kuwait

This illustrative template must be adapted to the judgment and case file, with the required service details, signatures and procedural formalities completed.

Before the Court Competent to Hear the Appeal — Circuit (…)

Appellant: (…)
Civil ID number or legal entity details: (…)
Address: (…)
Represented by Lawyer (…), under Power of Attorney No. (…).

Respondent: (…)
Address and service details: (…).

Subject: Appeal against the judgment issued in Case No. (…) at the hearing held on (…)

First: The Judgment Appealed Against and the Facts

(…) brought the claim seeking (…), based on the following events: (…). The appellant submitted the following documents before the first-instance court: (…).

At the hearing held on (…), the court ruled as follows: (insert the operative part of the judgment accurately).

The appellant challenges the judgment insofar as it ordered (…) on the following grounds:

Second: Grounds of Appeal

Ground One: (…)

On page (…), the judgment states (…). The appellant objects to this finding because Document No. (…) establishes (…). This objection affects the outcome in the following way: (…).

Ground Two: (…)

The judgment relied on (…) when assessing compensation. However, the report or document (…) establishes (…). The appellant requests reconsideration of this item for the reasons stated.

Ground Three, Where Applicable: (…)

Before the first-instance court, the appellant raised a defence to the effect that (…) in the memorandum submitted on (…). The effect of this defence on the relief sought is as follows: (…).

Third: Relief Sought

The appellant respectfully requests that the court:

1. Declare the appeal admissible.

2. On the merits, set aside or vary the challenged part of the judgment and order (…) (specify the relief and amount precisely).

3. Alternatively, where necessary, appoint an expert or direct further expert examination of the following specific issues: (…).

4. Order the respondent to pay costs and the allowance for legal fees in accordance with the law.

Attachments: Copy of the judgment, power of attorney, document bundle, explanatory memorandum and any documents required for registration.

Lawyer: (…)
Date: (…)
Signature: (…).

Drafting a Request to Increase Compensation

Depending on the case file, the request may be worded as follows:

Vary the judgment appealed against insofar as it awarded compensation of KWD (…), and award KWD (…), within the scope of the relief that may lawfully be sought on appeal, based on the documents identified in the statement of appeal.

As a general rule, new claims are inadmissible on appeal, subject to statutory exceptions, including increases in compensation arising after the final submissions before the first-instance court. The original amount claimed and any subsequent increase should therefore be examined before drafting the request.

The rule preventing an appellant’s position from being worsened by their own appeal alone does not require the court to increase compensation. An increase must have a supporting basis.

Source: Civil and Commercial Procedure Law, Articles 127 and 144.

Lawyers and Contact Details

This is Ineqad Law Firm’s general contact number, rather than any lawyer’s personal number. Appointments and case assignments are coordinated subject to availability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Judgment Dismissing a Compensation Claim Be Appealed?

Yes, provided the judgment is appealable and the appeal meets the applicable requirements. Preparing the challenge begins with identifying the reason for dismissal and how to address it.

Can a Reduction in Compensation Be Requested?

The party ordered to pay compensation may seek a reduction or the setting aside of the payment obligation, supported by specific objections and relevant documents.

Is New Evidence Required?

Not always. The objection may concern existing evidence or the application of the law. A distinction must be made between submitting a new defence or evidence and introducing a new claim.

Are Fraud or Forgery Required Grounds for an Appeal?

No. Grounds of appeal are not limited to fraud or forgery. Where either is involved, the appropriate challenge procedure and its effect on the deadline must be determined.

What Is the Difference Between Dismissal on the Merits and Inadmissibility?

Dismissal on the merits means that the court was not persuaded by the grounds for changing the judgment. Inadmissibility concerns a legal or procedural barrier. Missing the deadline results in loss of the right to appeal.

Contact Us About Appealing a Compensation Judgment

To arrange a review of your judgment and supporting documents, contact Ineqad Law Firm for Legal Consultation. Include the case number, judgment date, a copy of the judgment and service details, if available.

• Telephone and WhatsApp: +965 6666 8811

• Website: ineqad.com

• Email: info@ineqad.com